ArrieArrie HK StockScreener

Breakout versus VCP: compare Arrie's published pattern rules

Arrie's public rules describe two different pattern books. The breakout description uses a 5-day high and a 1.75× volume test against a stated 50-day average. The VCP description adds successive tighter swings, two volume dry-up tests and a 10-day-high breakout. [R] This guide compares those written conditions; it does not reconstruct the engine or identify a live setup.

Put the two descriptions side by side

Component Breakout description VCP description
Context Leading stock with a tight, shallow, not-yet-extended base Successive tighter swings
High being broken 5-day high 10-day high
Breakout volume At least 1.75× the 50-day average At least 1.5× average; the averaging window is not specified in this sentence
Explicit dry-up tests No additional numeric dry-up pair is specified in this paragraph 10-day average volume <85% of the 40-day; 5-day average volume ≤60% of the 50-day

Every entry above is an attributed summary of the pattern paragraph. [R] The absence of a number from that paragraph is not proof that the implementation has no other checks. In particular, the page does not specify the number of tightening swings or the averaging window for VCP breakout volume.

Breakout example: isolate the stated volume comparison

Fictional inputs, not a trade or actual candidate. Suppose the supplied 5-day high is HK$10, the illustrative price is HK$10.20, the 50-day average share volume is 100,000 and the observed volume supplied for the exercise is 180,000.

This does not establish the qualitative base description, other gates, calculation timing or actual screen membership.

VCP example: the two dry-up tests must be read separately

For a second fictional worksheet, supply a 40-day average volume of 100,000, a 10-day average of 80,000, a 50-day average of 100,000 and a 5-day average of 60,000.

Published test Arithmetic Result for this comparison
10-day average <85% of 40-day average 80,000 <0.85 × 100,000 =85,000 Meets the strict inequality
5-day average ≤60% of 50-day average 60,000 ≤0.60 × 100,000 =60,000 Meets the inclusive inequality

If the 10-day average were exactly 85,000, it would not be below 85,000. Do not read a strict “below” test as an inclusive one. The exercise still supplies no swing sequence or verified 10-day-high breakout.

What remains unknown?

Consult the public rules for the descriptions, and leave unspecified implementation details unresolved. Do not substitute a remembered textbook definition for the product's wording. Use the four-stage guide for the other gates and the research-note guide to record missing evidence. Passing the illustrated comparisons is not a recommendation or prediction.

Sources and review scope

Rules checked against current public publisher documentation on 22 November 2026. All worked examples use invented inputs; arithmetic was checked. This review does not independently verify production execution, current stock qualification, model accuracy or trading outcomes. AI-assisted writing, translation and editorial review.

Related guides